Who got Robbed? VAR, Cards, and Chaos: A Look at the World Cup Group Stages

Credit: Getty images

The 2026 World Cup in North America was supposed to be a massive celebration of football. Instead, fans and players are spending a lot of time arguing about the Video Assistant Referee. VAR was introduced to fix clear mistakes, but the group stages showed that it often creates more confusion. Let us look at some of the biggest controversies and see who really got robbed.

Heartbreak for Iran

The biggest issue so far is the automated offside technology. It measures offside calls perfectly, leaving no room for human error. However, this strict system has broken many hearts. Iran  felt this the most in their match against Egypt . Shoja Khalilzadeh scored a late goal that would have sent Iran to the next round. But the technology showed he was offside by just a millimeter. The goal was canceled, and Iran was eliminated. Sky Sports pundits were left in disbelief, with analysts arguing that while mathematically correct, decisions like this destroy the raw emotion of the sport.

Colombia Denied Perfection

Colombia  suffered a similar fate against Portugal . Davinson Sanchez scored a late header, but it was ruled out because his toe was offside. The decision sparked outrage across the football world. 

Speaking on the broadcast, pundit Wayne Rooney blasted the decision, arguing that VAR has gone too far by ruining iconic World Cup moments over a millimeter margin.

Ghana's Ignored Penalty

While offside is a strict rule, fouls and penalties are based on the referee's opinion. VAR is only supposed to step in for obvious mistakes, but this rule is applied inconsistently. For example, Ghana  tied England  zero to zero, but Ghana was denied a clear penalty. 

In the closing stages of the match, Prince Kwabena Adu drove into the penalty area and tried to cut inside. England defender Ezri Konsa lunged in with an outstretched leg, completely missing the ball and bringing Adu down hard on the knee. 

Despite the clear contact halting the attacker's run, the referee waved play on and VAR did nothing. Ghana head coach Carlos Queiroz was very angry. 

He told the media directly, "I'm not sure VAR is still working in the World Cup. We still have VAR? It's working? I have some doubts about that because another penalty that they need give to Ghana, a clear penalty against England was missed. Once again, VAR went for a coffee." 

TV pundits agreed with the frustration. Studio analysts covering the game noted that Konsa clearly missed the ball, calling the lack of intervention a baffling oversight.

Brazil's Soft Foul

On the other hand, Brazil  had a great goal canceled against Scotland  because VAR told the referee to review a very minor foul. Vinicius Junior fired a brilliant shot into the net, but the replay showed that earlier in the attacking sequence, a Brazilian player had lightly clipped the heel of Scotland defender Jack Hendry as they jockeyed for position. 

Hendry went down, and the referee was called to the monitor to disallow the goal. The BBC punditry team clashed over the call. James McFadden believed the VAR decision was correct because Hendry was impeded, but former referee expert Darren Cann disagreed. 

Cann argued the contact was minimal and called Scotland lucky to get the decision. This inconsistency caused Brazil to officially complain to FIFA.

Messi's Unpunished Tackle

Another major controversy happened when Argentina  beat Algeria  three to zero. In the first half, Algerian captain Aissa Mandi was shielding the ball when Lionel Messi came in from behind with a clumsy, studs up challenge. 

Messi stepped directly onto the back of Mandi's calf, leaving the defender writhing on the ground in pain. The referee called a foul but did not give a card, and the VAR booth stayed silent instead of reviewing it for a potential dismissal. 

Messi stayed in the game and scored three goals. Algeria was furious over the decision. Coach Vladimir Petkovic stated, "It is pointless to comment on hypothetical situations, but everyone saw it, including me." 

Television expert Ale Moreno called it a guaranteed red card and said great players like Messi get special treatment. Football player Marcelo agreed, saying it was clearly a red card but nothing happened because it was Messi.

The Invisible Offside Graphic

Sometimes the technology just stops working. During a game between Switzerland  and Qatar , Breel Embolo scored a penalty. The penalty itself came after a chaotic scramble in the box where a Qatari defender mistimed a slide tackle, wiping out a Swiss forward. 

However, there was a question about an offside pass before the foul even happened. The television broadcast never showed the usual offside graphic to clear things up. A technical problem meant fans and commentators had to trust a decision they could not see. 

The ITV commentary team was baffled during the live broadcast. Lee Dixon stated there was no doubt about the penalty but was adamant the player was offside, noting the referee could not see it. 

Fellow pundit Ian Wright called the lack of communication a scandal, while Gary Neville blasted the situation on air, expressing disbelief over the total lack of transparency.

Cards, Chaos, and the Road Ahead

The tension is not just about VAR. Referees are being very strict about bad tackles and players arguing. Many cards were given in the group stages as players tried to adjust to the new rules. As the tournament moves to the knockout games, the pressure will only grow. 

Technology can measure exact distances, but football is a game of human emotion. Until that balance is fixed, fans will keep shouting that their team was robbed.